Is it worth selling broken gold jewelry?
In short
- Weigh it, note the fineness, and calculate the metal value before speaking to anyone. That number is your benchmark for every offer.
- Expect to be offered a percentage of the metal value rather than all of it. Refiners and buyers have costs, and a fair offer is not the full spot price.
- Check for marks, old cut stones and maker's punches before anything is melted, because melting is the one decision that cannot be undone.
Yes, almost always, and the useful question is not whether to sell it but whether to sell it as metal. Broken gold has a guaranteed floor that almost nothing else in a jewelry box has, and the mistake people make is not underselling it. It is melting something that was worth far more intact.
Work out the number yourself first
This takes two minutes and it changes every conversation that follows.
- Weigh it in grams. Kitchen scales are close enough for an estimate.
- Find the fineness from the mark: 375 or 9K, 585 or 14K, 750 or 18K, 916 or 22K.
- Multiply. Weight in grams, times the gold proportion, times the current gold price per gram.
| Mark | Gold proportion |
|---|---|
| 375 / 9K | 0.375 |
| 585 / 14K | 0.585 |
| 750 / 18K | 0.750 |
| 916 / 22K | 0.916 |
So 12 grams of 585 gold contains about 7 grams of pure gold, and 7 times the current price per gram is your raw metal value.
Two adjustments. Deduct for anything that is not gold: stones, steel spring bars, clasps made of other metal. And expect to be offered a percentage of that number rather than all of it, because refining, assaying, transport and margin are real costs. A fair offer is not the full spot price, and any buyer promising one is making it back somewhere else.
Before anything goes to melt
This is the part worth slowing down for, because melting is the only decision in this whole subject that cannot be undone.
Check the marks. A maker's punch or a full hallmark row can multiply the value. Photograph anything you cannot read and ask before you sell.
Check the stones. Old cut diamonds, with slightly irregular facets and often a visible flat or opening at the point beneath, are scarce and valuable. Have them removed rather than melted with the mount.
Check whether it is actually broken. A snapped jump ring, a bent pin, a failed clasp and a loose stone are all routine repairs, often costing very little. A chain that has broken in one link is not a scrap chain, it is a chain with a broken link.
Check the design. Heavy period chains, Victorian brooches, signed silver and anything unusual sell as jewelry for well above metal, even in imperfect condition.
Repair or sell as metal?
| Situation | Usually |
|---|---|
| Broken clasp on a heavy chain | Repair. Cheap, and restores full jewelry value |
| Snapped fine chain, low weight | Sell as metal. Repair costs more than the piece is worth |
| Single earring, no partner | Sell as metal, unless it is signed or antique |
| Bent or crushed antique piece | Get it assessed. Do not melt it on your own judgement |
| Ring with a worn-through shank | Repair if the piece has marks, stones or age |
| Modern plated or gold filled | No metal value. Sell as jewelry or keep |
That last row catches people out. Gold filled and plated pieces have effectively no recoverable metal value, so a refiner will decline them. Their only value is as jewelry.
Where to sell scrap
Get at least two or three offers, because the percentage of spot value varies more between buyers than people expect. Weigh the pieces yourself first so you can check their scale against yours. Sell to buyers who weigh in front of you and price by fineness rather than lumping everything together at the lowest rate present.
And keep the pieces that made you hesitate. If you are not sure whether something is worth more than its weight, that hesitation is usually right, and the metal will still be there next month.
Common questions
How much is broken gold worth?
Its weight in gold, adjusted for fineness, minus the buyer's margin. Weigh the piece in grams, multiply by the proportion of gold in the alloy, 0.375 for 9K, 0.585 for 14K, 0.750 for 18K, and multiply by the current gold price per gram. That gives you the raw metal value before anyone's margin.
Will I get the full gold price?
No, and no honest buyer offers it. Refining, assaying, transport and the buyer's own margin all come out of the number, so offers typically land at a percentage of spot value. Comparing two or three offers tells you quickly what the going rate is where you are.
Should I repair a broken piece before selling?
Only if the repair is cheap relative to the piece's value as jewelry. A snapped clasp on a good chain is worth fixing; extensive repairs to an ordinary piece rarely return their cost. If it has marks, age or old cut stones, get it assessed before deciding.
What should I check before melting anything?
Marks, maker's punches, old stone cuts and any sign of age. Melting is irreversible, and pieces worth ten times their metal value go into the crucible every week because nobody looked first.
Do the stones have any value?
Sometimes. Old cut diamonds and good coloured stones retain value and should be removed rather than melted with the mount, which destroys them or damages them. Small modern stones usually are not worth the labour of removal.
Nextmine is a marketplace for jewelry that has already had one life. Buyers pay into escrow, sellers are paid once the piece has arrived, and every listing is someone's own photographs of their own piece.
Browse the pieces for sale·How payments work·Questions and answers